diff --git a/src/channel/whatsappUtils.js b/src/channel/whatsappUtils.js
index d987438..517cf9a 100644
--- a/src/channel/whatsappUtils.js
+++ b/src/channel/whatsappUtils.js
@@ -252,7 +252,7 @@ const whatsappMsgMapped = {
       id: msgcontent.wamid,
       status: msgStatusRenderMapped[(msgcontent?.status || 'failed')],
       sender: 'me',
-      dateString: msgcontent.status==='failed' ? `发送失败 ${whatsappError?.[msgcontent.errorCode] || msgcontent.errorMessage} ❌` : '',
+      dateString: msgcontent.status==='failed' ? `发送失败 ${whatsappError?.[msgcontent.errorCode] || msgcontent.errorMessage || ''} ❌` : '',
     }),
   },
 };
@@ -552,7 +552,7 @@ export const parseRenderMessageList = (messages) => {
             sender: 'me',
             senderName: 'me',
             status: msgStatusRenderMapped[msgContent?.status || 'failed'],
-            dateString: msgStatusRenderMapped[msgContent?.status || 'failed'] === 'failed' ? `${(msg.msgtime || '').replace('T', ' ')} 发送失败 ${whatsappError?.[msgContent.errorCode] || msgContent.errorMessage} ❌` : '',
+            dateString: msgStatusRenderMapped[msgContent?.status || 'failed'] === 'failed' ? `${(msg.msgtime || '').replace('T', ' ')} 发送失败 ${whatsappError?.[msgContent.errorCode] || msgContent.errorMessage || ''} ❌` : '',
             statusCN: msgStatusRenderMappedCN[msgContent?.status || 'failed'],
             statusTitle: msgStatusRenderMappedCN[msgContent?.status || 'failed'],
           }